The Carla Jan Walker Case: A Fort Worth Cold Case That Waited 46 Years for a Name

Some cases go cold because no one cares.

The Carla Jan Walker case was not one of them.

For decades, her name stayed with Fort Worth. It stayed with her family. It stayed with the people who remembered the night a 17-year-old girl went to a school dance and never came home. Carla was a Western Hills High School student, and her murder became one of the best-known cold cases in Fort Worth history.

Carla Jan Walker was only 17 years old in February 1974. She had gone to a Valentine’s dance with her boyfriend, Rodney McCoy. After the dance, they stopped at Brunswick Ridglea Bowl in Fort Worth. They were sitting in Rodney’s car when a man opened the door, pulled Carla out, and attacked Rodney. Rodney was beaten and left dazed. Carla was taken.

Carlas Home

Residence Private – View From Public Area Drive up

Carla Walkers House – Carla lived at this house in Fort Worth with her parents

Image Taken From: Fort Worth, TX 76116, USA

Latitude: 32.7131223 Longitude: -97.45255510000001

View Map

Take me to this place with

Google Waze Apple

Nearby Cases 12 cases near this location

Three days later, Carla’s body was found in a culvert near Benbrook Lake. The court record says she had been strangled and had likely been sexually assaulted.

That is the part of the story that sits heavy.

Carla was not a headline. She was not just “a victim.” She was a daughter, a student, a friend, and a young woman who should have had a whole life ahead of her.

Western Hills High School

School / Campus Limited Access Drive up

Western Hills High School, it was here that Carla was attending school at the time of her murder.

Image Taken From: 8033 Boston Ave, Benbrook, TX 76116, USA

Latitude: 32.7193112 Longitude: -97.4544311

View Map

Take me to this place with

Google Waze Apple

Nearby Cases 12 cases near this location

Attack Site

Crime Scene Public

Carla Walker Attack Site

Image Taken From: 3609 Marquita Dr, Fort Worth, TX 76116, USA

Latitude: 32.7190797 Longitude: -97.4434038

View Map

Take me to this place with

Google Waze Apple

Nearby Cases 12 cases near this location

The Clue That Was There From the Beginning

The first investigation did not have nothing. That is what makes this case so frustrating.

Police had a piece of evidence from the parking lot: a magazine from a Ruger pistol. Investigators looked at people in the Fort Worth area who owned that type of gun. One of those people was Glen Samuel McCurley. When police interviewed him in 1974, he said his pistol had been stolen before Carla’s murder. He was given a polygraph test and released. After that, the case went cold.

Cold does not mean forgotten.

It means the answers were out of reach.

For Carla’s family, those years were not just dates on a calendar. They were birthdays, holidays, and normal days when the same question still had no answer.

Who took Carla?

The Case Reopened

In 2019, investigators reopened the Carla Walker case. They went back to the old evidence and the old suspect list. This time, science had changed. Evidence from the original case was sent for DNA testing. A single-source male DNA profile was developed from genetic material found on Carla’s bra. When that profile did not match anyone in the FBI’s national DNA database, it was sent to Othram, a lab that uses forensic-grade genomic sequencing. Othram’s work pointed detectives toward the surname McCurley.

That name was not new.

It had been in the file since 1974.

Detectives learned that Glen Samuel McCurley still lived in Fort Worth. They collected discarded trash from outside his home. DNA from a drinking straw matched the male DNA profile from Carla’s bra. McCurley later gave investigators a voluntary DNA sample. That sample matched too.

After 46 years, the case had moved from suspicion to evidence.

The Arrest of Glen Samuel McCurley

Glen Samuel McCurley was arrested in September 2020. He was 77 years old. Othram’s case page says he was apprehended by Fort Worth police and charged with capital murder on September 21, 2020.

That arrest did not undo what happened to Carla. Nothing could.

But it gave her family something they had waited decades to hear: a name.

Not a rumor.

Not a theory.

A name backed by DNA.

The Trial and Guilty Plea

McCurley went to trial in August 2021. After two days of jury trial proceedings, he changed his plea to guilty. He was sentenced to life in prison for capital murder. The Texas Court of Appeals later affirmed the case after McCurley appealed issues tied to DNA evidence and his statement to law enforcement.

The Tarrant County District Attorney’s Office later noted that McCurley died in prison during the summer of 2023.

That is where the legal story ends.

But it is not where Carla’s story ends.

Remembering Carla

It is easy in true crime to focus on the killer. The arrest. The DNA. The courtroom. The confession.

But Carla should stay at the center of this story.

She was 17. She went to a dance. She should have gone home. She should have grown older. She should have had the chance to become whoever she was going to be.

The man who killed her lost his freedom late in life.

Carla lost everything before hers had really begun.

That is why her case still hits so hard. It is not just a solved cold case. It is a reminder that time does not erase grief. It also does not erase evidence, not always.

Sometimes the truth sits in a box for decades.

Sometimes it waits for the right test.

And sometimes, after 46 years, it finally gets a name.

Carlas Grave

Grave / Memorial Public Easy walk

Grave of Carla Walker. When we visited the grave was completely covered up so we used a picture from Find a Grave. Hopefully someone sees this and will know how to get her grave cleaned up, or if it has been please drop us a message so we can revisit it and take a better picture.

Image Taken From: Greenwood Cemetery, Fort Worth, TX 76107, USA

Latitude: 32.7649605 Longitude: -97.3705509

View Map

Take me to this place with

Google Waze Apple

Nearby Cases 12 cases near this location