Story timelineChoose a date or event
Two days before Thanksgiving, Rob Andrew went to pick up his children.
It was Tuesday, November 20, 2001. Oklahoma City’s recorded temperatures ranged from a freezing low of 26 degrees to an afternoon high of 54, with no measurable precipitation. The previous day had brought rain and a high of 61; Tuesday was cooler and dry. These are city weather records, rather than a measurement at the Andrew home, but they place the evening in its late-autumn setting. Thanksgiving was two days away. Rob had come to collect his two children for the holiday (“Oklahoma City Weather”; Andrew v. White).
Rob was 39. He and his wife, Brenda, had separated, and he no longer lived in the house. Usually, she brought the children outside to meet him. That evening, she asked him into the garage to help relight the furnace’s pilot light.
Around 7 p.m., Rob was shot.
To understand what was lost in that garage, Rob’s story has to begin years earlier, in Enid, Oklahoma.
A life built around people
Born on September 19, 1962, in Enid, Rob was the son of E.R. and Lou Ellen Andrew. He graduated from Chisholm High School in 1980 and earned an advertising degree with a marketing minor from Oklahoma State University in 1984 (“Rob Andrew”).
Brenda’s sister recalled a summer meeting at a swimming pool; the couple began dating during Brenda’s senior year of high school (Smith).
Charles Montaldo’s account identifies Rob’s younger brother as the connection between them and places Rob at Oklahoma State University when they met. Brenda initially attended college in Winfield, Kansas, after high school, then transferred to OSU to be closer to Rob (Montaldo).
Rob and Brenda married on June 2, 1984—the date recorded in his obituary, and the same year he completed his degree. They later spent time in Texas before returning to Oklahoma. By the time they separated in 2001, they had been married for seventeen years (“Rob Andrew”; Montaldo).
Advertising became his career. At Jordan Associates, which he joined in 1988, he rose to senior vice president and directed telecommunications accounts. His obituary noted national industry recognition, public speaking, and the respect of clients and coworkers. He also served on the boards of Positive Tomorrows and Junior Achievement and had been a church deacon (“Rob Andrew”).
At home, he was Dad to Tricity, 10, and Parker, 7. His obituary preserved a small pleasure: letting his children beat him at Nintendo. That memory gives the professional accomplishments a personal counterpart—a father enjoying his children’s victories (“Rob Andrew”).
Other memories survived in reporting by Ken Raymond five years after Rob’s death. His coworker and confidante Barb Murcer-Green recalled the man she had come to know across the hall at Jordan Associates. His second cousin, Dave Parker, remembered a friendly, smiling person inclined to see good in others (Raymond).
Raymond’s account also preserved Rob’s playful streak: bringing slushes for people at work to mark July 11 as “7-Eleven day,” and the family joke that Tricity could someday campaign for office with the slogan “Elect Tricity.” These recollections give him a presence beyond a courtroom photograph. They describe someone who could turn an ordinary workday or a child’s name into a reason to smile (Raymond).

Explore this location
A circle of trust breaks
Church was another part of the family’s life. It was also where their lives intersected with James Pavatt.
Pavatt attended the same congregation and taught Sunday school with Brenda. He socialized with the Andrews and worked as an insurance agent. Rob obtained an approximately $800,000 life insurance policy through him.
By 2001, Pavatt and Brenda were having an affair. In late September, Rob moved out of the family home; divorce proceedings followed. A man who had entered the family’s circle through church and insurance was now involved with Rob’s wife (Pavatt v. Royal).


Church photograph & location

The first warning
Then came a warning that Rob took seriously.
During the night of October 25–26, someone severed the brake lines on his car. The next morning, he received calls claiming Brenda was in a hospital in Norman and urgently needed him. Trial testimony later connected one of those calls to Pavatt’s daughter, acting at her father’s request.
Rob discovered the damage before driving the car into danger. He contacted police (Andrew v. State, par. 13).
The calls mattered because they supplied a reason to hurry. According to testimony and telephone records summarized on appeal, one originated at a pay phone near Larson’s workplace in Norman; another came from south Oklahoma City. The prosecution presented the combination of disabled brakes and a false emergency as an attempt to put Rob on the road in a dangerous car (Andrew v. State, par. 13).
The next day, Brenda told Rob she had read about the damaged brakes in the newspaper. The appellate account states that no such coverage had appeared. Investigators would later examine that remark alongside the calls, the insurance dispute, and testimony about the planning of his death (Andrew v. State, pars. 13–14).

Rob tries to protect himself
Rob also tried to change the beneficiary of his life insurance. Pavatt told him Brenda owned the policy and that he could not control it. Rob went above him to a supervisor, who said Rob remained the recorded owner. He then explained his suspicion that Brenda and Pavatt were trying to kill him (Pavatt v. Royal).
The court record describes evidence that Brenda and Pavatt had attempted to transfer ownership to her using a forged signature and a backdated form. Rob’s effort to change the policy was therefore part of a broader struggle over who controlled it. The person who had helped arrange his insurance was also someone Rob now feared (Pavatt v. Royal).
He had recognized a threat and sought help. The redacted police report reproduced alongside this section, dated November 2, records his suspicion that the brake incident and insurance money were connected. Yet he still shared two children with Brenda, and arrangements for their care continued. On the Tuesday before Thanksgiving, he returned to collect them (Oklahoma City Police Department).

A father’s last visit
While waiting in his car for the garage to open that evening, Rob spoke with a friend on his cell phone. When the door opened, he ended the call. The appellate record preserves that ordinary transition: a conversation finished, a father going inside. Neighbors heard shots a short time later (Pavatt v. State, par. 5).
Inside the garage that evening, Rob suffered two shotgun wounds.
Brenda called 911 and said masked intruders had attacked them. She also had a wound to her arm. Emergency responders found Rob on the garage floor and could not revive him.
The children were inside the house, watching television in a bedroom with the volume turned up high. According to the court’s account, they were unaware of what had happened in the garage (Andrew v. White).
The investigation challenged Brenda’s account. Rob had been shot with a shotgun, while her arm injury came from a .22-caliber weapon. Prosecutors argued that her wound had been inflicted to make her appear to be another victim. They built a case that Rob’s killing was planned and that the insurance policy supplied a financial motive (Andrew v. White).
The evidence also reached into familiar places around the family. A 16-gauge shotgun Rob owned was missing. Police found a spent shell in the garage. In a neighboring house, investigators recovered another shotgun shell and .22-caliber ammunition; the appellate account states that Brenda had a key to that house. Such details became part of the prosecution’s effort to connect the people, weapons, and movements surrounding the shooting (Andrew v. White).


Explore this location
The years after
In the days after Rob’s death, Brenda and Pavatt left for Mexico with the children. They were arrested while returning to the United States in February 2002 (Andrew v. State, par. 11).
Pavatt was tried in 2003. Brenda’s separate trial followed in 2004. Both were convicted of murder and conspiracy, and both received death sentences for Rob’s killing (Pavatt v. State, par. 1; Andrew v. State, pars. 1–2).
The case continues
Years of appeals followed, including a substantial dispute over the conduct of Brenda’s prosecution. Her trial included extensive evidence about her clothing, sexual history, and behavior as a wife and mother. In January 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court sent her case back for further consideration of whether irrelevant, prejudicial evidence had made the trial fundamentally unfair. The decision did not acquit her or order a new trial (Andrew v. White, Supreme Court).
The distinction matters to the history of Rob’s case. The justices were considering the legal standard for evaluating a claim of an unfair trial. They expressly left the prejudice analysis to the appeals court and did not decide the strength of the evidence against Brenda. The murder convictions and the challenge to the fairness of her trial belong in the same account, with each described accurately (Andrew v. White, Supreme Court).
The Tenth Circuit again denied relief in January 2026, and rehearing was denied in August. Brenda filed another Supreme Court petition in September; as of November 15, 2026, it remained pending and had been distributed for the Court’s December 4 conference (“Brenda Evers Andrew”).
James Pavatt executed for Rob Andrew’s murder
On Thursday, November 12, 2026, Oklahoma executed James Pavatt by lethal injection at the Oklahoma State Penitentiary in McAlester. He was 73. The Oklahoma Department of Corrections recorded his time of death as 10:12 a.m. Central Standard Time. The execution came eight days before the twenty-fifth anniversary of Rob Andrew’s murder (Hoberock, “Oklahoma County Killer Put to Death”; Goforth).
The Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board had voted 3–2 against recommending clemency in October. On the day of the execution, the U.S. Supreme Court denied Pavatt’s application for a stay and his petition for review. Pavatt had continued to maintain his innocence as the execution approached and made no final statement in the death chamber (Hoberock, “Oklahoma County Killer Put to Death”; Pavatt v. Oklahoma; Goforth).
No members of Rob’s family or Pavatt’s family witnessed the execution, according to a Department of Corrections spokesperson quoted by Oklahoma Voice. Afterward, Attorney General Gentner Drummond described the execution as justice for Rob and expressed hope that his family might find some peace after years of grief. Pavatt’s execution did not resolve Brenda Andrew’s separate challenge to her conviction and death sentence (Hoberock, “Oklahoma County Killer Put to Death”; Oklahoma Office of the Attorney General).
The life beyond the case
Those proceedings belong in an accurate account of the case. But Rob’s life deserves space beyond the arguments over his killers.
The loss continued through the years in which those arguments were heard. Rob’s parents raised Tricity and Parker. By the 2026 clemency proceedings, both parents had died, according to reporting on a letter submitted by Rob’s brothers. The brothers described an absence that had remained with the family through nearly a quarter-century (Hoberock, “Oklahoma County Killer to Seek Clemency”).
“Vengeance is not ours,” they wrote. “Our brother is gone and we cannot change that.” Their words place the legal proceedings beside the family’s lasting reality: whatever decision a court or parole board reached, it could not return Rob to them (Hoberock, “Oklahoma County Killer to Seek Clemency”).
He was a son from Enid who built a career in Oklahoma City. A colleague, a volunteer, a church member. A father who found pleasure in a game his children could win.
His funeral was held on November 26, 2001, at Crossings Community Church. He was buried at Resurrection Memorial Cemetery (“Rob Andrew”).
On his final evening, Rob had gone to pick up Tricity and Parker for Thanksgiving.
He never got to take them home.

Memorial location
Works Cited18 linked references
Sources are listed in MLA style. Parenthetical citations identify the supporting work; “Supreme Court” distinguishes the 2025 Andrew v. White decision from the 2023 appeals-court opinion. Legal status was checked on November 15, 2026. Location photographs and the reproduced police record are from this site’s existing article materials. The Brenda Andrew and James Pavatt portraits are credited to the Oklahoma Department of Corrections via Bustle.
Reader Notes
Add to the story.
Share a memory, correction, lead, or detail that helps the place come into focus.
Leave a note